Saggi Law Firm Blog

What Is a Criminal Lawyer? Roles, Responsibilities, and When to Hire One

8 min read

A criminal lawyer is a legal professional who represents people accused of criminal offences, protects their legal rights, and helps them navigate the criminal justice system. In Canada, a criminal lawyer can provide legal advice, review prosecution evidence, represent clients at bail hearings and trials, negotiate resolutions, and develop a defence strategy based on the facts of a case.

Facing criminal charges can be stressful, especially when you are unfamiliar with court procedures, potential penalties, or your rights under Canadian law. Understanding what a criminal lawyer does can help you make informed decisions and determine when professional legal representation may be necessary.

At Saggi Law Firm, individuals facing criminal allegations can explore their legal options and seek guidance tailored to their circumstances in Ontario.

In this article (click to open)
  1. What Does a Criminal Lawyer Do?
  2. What Is the Difference Between a Criminal Lawyer and a Criminal Defence Lawyer?
  3. What Types of Cases Do Criminal Lawyers Handle?
  4. What Happens After an Arrest in Ontario?
  5. How Does a Criminal Defence Lawyer Build a Case?
  6. Can a Criminal Lawyer Get Charges Dropped?
  7. How Much Does a Criminal Lawyer Cost in Ontario?
  8. How to Choose the Right Criminal Lawyer
  9. Protect Your Rights With Guidance From Saggi Law Firm
  10. Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Lawyers

What Does a Criminal Lawyer Do?

A criminal lawyer helps individuals understand criminal charges, assess available evidence, and navigate legal proceedings. Their responsibilities depend on the allegations, the stage of the case, and the client's circumstances.

1. Provides Legal Advice

A criminal lawyer explains the charges, relevant laws, possible consequences, and available legal options. They help clients understand court dates, procedural requirements, and the potential implications of entering a guilty or not-guilty plea.

Legal advice is particularly important before making statements to investigators or decisions that could affect the outcome of a case.

2. Investigates the Evidence

A criminal defence lawyer examines the circumstances surrounding an alleged offence. This may involve reviewing police reports, witness statements, surveillance footage, digital records, forensic evidence, and other relevant material.

The lawyer assesses whether the evidence supports the allegations and identifies inconsistencies, weaknesses, or potential Charter of Rights and Freedoms issues.

3. Represents Clients in Court

Criminal lawyers represent clients in criminal court proceedings, including bail hearings, pre-trial appearances, motions, and trials.

They can question witnesses through cross-examination, challenge evidence where legally appropriate, make submissions to the court, and present a defence based on the evidence and applicable law.

4. Negotiates Case Resolutions

Not every criminal case proceeds to trial. Depending on the circumstances, a defence lawyer may communicate with the Crown prosecutor about a possible resolution, including plea negotiations or an agreed position on sentencing.

A lawyer should explain the advantages and risks of available options so that the client can make an informed decision.

What Is the Difference Between a Criminal Lawyer and a Criminal Defence Lawyer?

The terms criminal lawyer, criminal defence lawyer, criminal attorney, and defence counsel are often used interchangeably in Canada to describe a lawyer who represents individuals facing criminal allegations.

However, criminal law involves different legal roles.

  • Criminal defence lawyer: Represents the accused and protects their legal interests.
  • Defence counsel: Another term for the lawyer acting for the accused.
  • Crown prosecutor: Represents the public prosecution and presents the Crown's case.
  • Criminal court: The judicial forum where criminal proceedings are heard and decided.

The defence lawyer and Crown prosecutor have different responsibilities. The prosecutor presents the case against the accused, while defence counsel examines the evidence, challenges the prosecution's position where appropriate, and advocates for the accused.

The accused is presumed innocent unless guilt is established according to the applicable legal standard.

What Types of Cases Do Criminal Lawyers Handle?

Criminal lawyers may handle a wide range of allegations under Canadian criminal law. The appropriate defence strategy depends on the specific charge, available evidence, and circumstances.

Common Criminal Charges in Ontario

Assault and Domestic Violence

Assault allegations can arise from physical confrontations, threats involving force, or other circumstances defined by law. Domestic violence cases may involve allegations between spouses, partners, family members, or people in domestic relationships.

These cases can raise additional concerns involving release conditions, no-contact orders, and restrictions on returning to a shared residence.

Theft and Fraud

Theft involves allegations of taking property without lawful justification, while fraud generally concerns dishonest conduct involving deprivation or risk of deprivation.

A defence lawyer may examine ownership records, financial documents, communications, witness accounts, and the evidence relating to the accused person's knowledge or intent.

Drug Offences

Drug-related criminal charges may involve possession, possession for the purpose of trafficking, trafficking, or production of controlled substances.

The legality of a search, the handling of seized evidence, and the prosecution's ability to establish the required elements may be relevant to the defence.

DUI and Impaired Driving

In Canada, impaired driving and other Criminal Code driving offences can result in serious legal consequences. Depending on the charge and circumstances, a case may involve breath or blood evidence, roadside procedures, driving records, and questions about the reliability or admissibility of evidence.

Weapons and Sexual Offences

Weapons offences and sexual offence allegations can carry significant consequences, potentially including imprisonment and long-term restrictions. These cases require careful examination of the evidence, applicable legal requirements, and the accused person's rights.

Other Criminal Matters

Criminal defence lawyers may also assist with youth criminal justice proceedings, bail variations, sentencing hearings, appeals, and cases involving allegations of wrongful conviction.

The potential consequences vary according to the offence, prior record, and other legally relevant factors.

What Happens After an Arrest in Ontario?

Understanding the criminal process can help you prepare for the next steps if you or someone you know is arrested.

Step 1: Arrest and Police Investigation

Police may investigate an alleged offence, question witnesses, collect evidence, and arrest a suspect when the legal requirements are met.

A person's rights during detention and questioning depend on the circumstances. Section 10 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms provides protections upon arrest or detention, including the right to be informed promptly of the reasons and the right to retain and instruct counsel without delay.

Step 2: Contacting a Criminal Lawyer

Seeking legal advice early can help you understand your rights and avoid making uninformed decisions. If you are detained, you should clearly request access to a lawyer and exercise your applicable rights.

A lawyer can explain the process and advise you based on the available information.

Step 3: Bail Hearing and Release Conditions

If you are not released by police, you may need to attend a bail hearing. The court considers the applicable legal criteria when deciding whether you should be released and under what conditions.

A criminal lawyer may present information relevant to release, address the proposed conditions, and help arrange a suitable surety where appropriate.

A surety is generally a person who agrees to supervise or support compliance with bail conditions under the terms of a bail order.

Step 4: Disclosure and Case Preparation

The Crown generally provides relevant disclosure to the defence, subject to applicable legal rules. Disclosure can include witness statements, police notes, video recordings, and other evidence relevant to the prosecution's case.

Defence counsel reviews the material, identifies legal issues, considers further investigation, and prepares for negotiations, pre-trial proceedings, or trial.

Step 5: Trial, Resolution, or Sentencing

A case may conclude through a negotiated resolution, a guilty plea, a withdrawal or stay of proceedings, or a trial verdict.

If there is a conviction, the court determines the appropriate sentence under the applicable law. Depending on the circumstances, a person may also have grounds to appeal a conviction or sentence.

How Does a Criminal Defence Lawyer Build a Case?

Building a criminal defence requires a careful review of the evidence, the law, and the prosecution's ability to prove the alleged offence.

Reviewing the Prosecution's Evidence

The lawyer assesses whether the available evidence supports each essential element of the charge. This may include reviewing witness credibility, forensic findings, digital evidence, police records, and inconsistencies between statements.

Examining Constitutional and Charter Rights

The defence may investigate whether police respected the accused person's constitutional rights during an arrest, detention, questioning, or search.

If a Charter breach is established, the lawyer may seek an appropriate remedy. In certain circumstances, this may include an application to exclude evidence under section 24(2) of the Charter. The result depends on the facts and applicable legal tests.

Challenging Evidence and Cross-Examining Witnesses

Where appropriate, defence counsel may challenge the reliability, relevance, or admissibility of evidence and question prosecution witnesses through cross-examination.

The objective is to ensure the case is assessed fairly and that the prosecution meets its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal trial.

Developing a Defence Strategy

Possible defence approaches vary by case and may involve challenging identification evidence, questioning intent, presenting relevant evidence, disputing the reliability of forensic findings, or raising a legally available defence.

No single strategy works for every allegation. A qualified lawyer must evaluate the evidence before advising on the appropriate approach.

Can a Criminal Lawyer Get Charges Dropped?

A criminal lawyer may be able to pursue a resolution that results in charges being withdrawn or stayed, but no lawyer can guarantee that criminal charges will be dropped.

The available options depend on the evidence, the applicable law, procedural issues, and decisions made by the Crown or the court.

A defence lawyer may identify evidentiary weaknesses, raise legal challenges, negotiate with the Crown, or seek an appropriate court ruling. In some cases, these steps can materially affect the outcome.

However, a weak-looking case does not automatically result in withdrawn charges, and a Charter challenge does not automatically lead to evidence being excluded.

How Much Does a Criminal Lawyer Cost in Ontario?

Criminal lawyer fees vary according to the complexity of the case, the seriousness of the allegations, the lawyer's experience, the expected workload, and whether the matter proceeds to trial.

A straightforward matter may require less preparation than a complex case involving multiple accused persons, extensive disclosure, expert witnesses, or several court appearances.

Before retaining a lawyer, ask about:

  • The fee structure and payment arrangements.
  • What services are included in the quoted fee.
  • Whether trial preparation and trial attendance are charged separately.
  • Potential additional expenses, including expert reports.
  • The expected scope of work and possible changes in cost.

Individuals who meet the eligibility requirements may also explore assistance through Legal Aid Ontario. Eligibility and coverage depend on the applicable criteria and the circumstances of the case.

How to Choose the Right Criminal Lawyer

Choosing legal representation is an important decision when you are facing criminal charges.

Look for Relevant Criminal Law Experience

Ask whether the lawyer regularly handles cases involving the specific allegations you face, such as assault, impaired driving, fraud, or drug offences.

Understand the Proposed Strategy

A lawyer should explain the legal issues, available options, potential risks, and likely next steps without promising a particular result.

Discuss Fees and Communication

Ask how you will receive updates, who will handle your case, how quickly inquiries are generally answered, and what the fee agreement covers.

Confirm Professional Credentials

Verify that the lawyer is licensed and in good standing with the Law Society of Ontario. You can also ask about their experience with the relevant courts and procedures.

Protect Your Rights With Guidance From Saggi Law Firm

Facing criminal charges can affect your freedom, reputation, employment, and future opportunities. Getting clear legal guidance can help you understand the allegations, assess your options, and prepare for the criminal justice process.

Saggi Law Firm provides legal services in criminal law. If you are facing a criminal allegation in Ontario, contact the firm to discuss your circumstances, ask about available legal services, and determine the appropriate next steps.

Do not assume that a charge automatically means a conviction. Every case depends on its facts, evidence, and applicable law. Early legal advice can help you make informed decisions about your defence.

Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Lawyers

1. What is a criminal lawyer?

A criminal lawyer is a legal professional who advises and represents individuals accused of criminal offences. Their work may include reviewing evidence, protecting legal rights, negotiating resolutions, representing clients in court, and preparing a defence.

2. When should I hire a criminal lawyer?

Consider seeking legal advice as soon as you learn that you are under investigation, have been arrested, or are facing criminal charges. Early advice can help you understand your rights and the potential consequences of important decisions.

3. Can I represent myself in a criminal case in Canada?

You may be permitted to represent yourself, but criminal proceedings involve legal rules, evidence requirements, and procedural obligations that can be difficult to navigate. Professional representation can help you understand the issues and protect your legal interests.

4. What is the difference between summary and indictable offences?

Under Canadian criminal law, summary conviction offences generally follow a less serious procedural category, while indictable offences are generally treated as more serious and can carry greater penalties. Some offences are hybrid, meaning the Crown may elect to proceed by summary conviction or indictment, subject to the law.

5. Can a criminal lawyer help with bail?

Yes. A criminal defence lawyer may represent an accused person at a bail hearing, present relevant information, address proposed release conditions, and assist with surety arrangements where appropriate.

6. Will hiring a criminal lawyer prevent a criminal record?

Not necessarily. The outcome depends on the charge, evidence, proceedings, and final disposition. A lawyer can explain possible outcomes and pursue appropriate legal options, but cannot guarantee that a criminal record will be avoided.

7. What is the presumption of innocence in Canada?

The presumption of innocence means an accused person is considered innocent unless and until guilt is established according to law. In a criminal trial, the prosecution generally must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

8. Are criminal lawyer fees covered by Legal Aid Ontario?

Eligible individuals may qualify for legal assistance through Legal Aid Ontario, depending on financial eligibility, the type of matter, and applicable program requirements. Contact Legal Aid Ontario to determine whether you qualify.

9. Can a criminal lawyer challenge evidence collected by police?

Yes. A defence lawyer can examine how evidence was obtained and challenge its admissibility where there are valid legal grounds. A court determines whether evidence should be excluded or another remedy granted.

10. How can Saggi Law Firm help with criminal charges?

Saggi Law Firm provides legal services that can help individuals understand their legal situation and available options. Contact the firm directly to discuss your circumstances, the services available, and the appropriate next steps.

Mandeep Saggi
Mandeep SaggiCriminal Defence Lawyer · Saggi Law Firm

Mandeep Saggi has represented clients in the Ontario Court of Justice and the Superior Court of Justice since 2013. Learn more about Saggi Law Firm or explore our criminal law services.

This article provides general legal information only and is not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts. Contact a lawyer for advice about your situation.